[Boost-users] [MP11] Loosing const-qualification on type result with GCC 4.8 only

25 Apr 2019

      Hi,

I prepared a lenghty MWE which reproduces my problem with
type manipulation using MP11 that for some reason looses
const-qualification on a ::type result

Here it is at https://godbolt.org/z/eCsakP
and copied below.
I hope the XXXXXX comments make sense and important static
assertions in the main() at the bottom explain what
is  the expected result.

```
#include 
#include <cstdint>
#include 
namespace mp11 = boost::mp11;

template 
struct bit_range_reference { /* long definition, irrelevant */ };

template 
struct bit_range_reference_type
{
    using type = bit_range_reference
    <
        BitField, FirstBit::value, NumBits::value, true
    > const; // XXXXXX Why this const gets lost with GCC 4.8 XXXXXX
};

template 
class bit_range_reference_list
{
    template 
    using reference_type = typename bit_range_reference_type
    <
        BitField, FirstBit, NumBits
    >::type; // XXXXXX Should carry the const, shouldn't? GCC >4.8 do.

    // If RangeBitSizes is mp11::mp_list_c
    // then first_bit_list will be mp11::mp_list_c
    using first_bit_list = mp11::mp_fold_q
        <
            RangeBitSizes,
            mp11::mp_list>,
            mp11::mp_bind
            <
                mp11::mp_push_back,
                mp11::_1,
                mp11::mp_bind
                <
                    mp11::mp_plus,
                    mp11::mp_bind,
                    mp11::_2
                >
            >
        >;
    static_assert(mp11::mp_at_c::value == 0,
        "first bit must be 0");
public:
    using type = mp11::mp_transform
        <
            reference_type,
            mp11::mp_pop_back,
            RangeBitSizes
        >;
};

using reference3_list = typename bit_range_reference_list
<
    std::uint8_t,
    mp11::mp_list_c
...
::type;
int main()
{
    using r1_t = mp11::mp_at_c;
    using r2_t = bit_range_reference;
    using r2c_t= bit_range_reference const;

//#if defined(__GNUC__) && (__GNUC__  == 4)
    // GCC 4.8 compiles, later versions of GCC fail to compile
    static_assert(std::is_same::value,
        "GCC says r1_t is const-qualified");
//#else
    // GCC 4.9, 5, 6, 7, 8 versions compile, GCC 4.8 fail to compile
    static_assert(std::is_same::value,
        "GCC says r1_t is NOT const-qualified");
//#endif
}
```

To summary, I expect this to yield true:

std::is_same
<
    mp11::mp_at_c
    bit_range_reference const
...
I got this confirmed by all GCC versions but GCC 4.8.
(clang and MSVC also seem to agree with the GCC >= 4.9)

Is mp11::mp_transform loosing const-qualification
or have I made a mistake somewhere?

I'm using Boost.MP11 from Boost 1.70 and from current develop branch

Best regards,
-- 
Mateusz Loskot, http://mateusz.loskot.net