On Fri, 27 Jan 2023 at 13:11, Klemens Morgenstern via Boost
Boost.aedis is ACCEPTED with conditions.
Accept: 3 ( + 1 late one) Conditional: 1 Reject: 4
All but one rejections asked for changes that were not fundamental to the design, but rather were about particular implementation details or high-level API design issues. Thus I conclude, based on the reviews, that there is no need for another mini-review. This is also based on Marcelo's engagement, so I am confident that many issues will be addressed in the future .
I would like to thank everybody that participated in the review in one way or another and more specifically * Klemens for offering to be the review manager. * All the people that submitted a review. Both of these roles are very time consuming and in fact many spent days reviewing Aedis. I can only be thankful to them. Suggested changes that are not part of the conditions for acceptance won't be neglected. I will revisit the discussion and implement them if meaningful. Regards, Marcelo