Re: [boost] [Thread] Doc bug?

On 8/01/2014 06:51, Quoth Alexander Lamaison:

Jonathan Wakely writes:

...

On 7 January 2014 16:11, Alexander Lamaison wrote:

...

The docs [1] for the `scoped_thread` and `strict_scoped_thread` says

...

"While thread call std::terminate() on the destructor is the thread is joinable, strict_scoped_thread<> or scoped_thread<> join the thread if joinable.

Several other places on the page say something similar.

I was under in the impression that Boost.Thread had toyed with adopting this behaviour to match `std::thread` but decided against it after complaints on this list. Am I wrong?

It depends on a macro, but the non-standard behaviour is deprecated: http://www.boost.org/doc/libs/1_55_0/doc/html/thread/thread_management.html#...

Hmmm, could have sworn I remembered the decision being reversed completely. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad it's being changed. Just not what I remembered.

The decision to make the default be the standard-compliant but prior-code-breaking version was reversed. Boost users currently have to explicitly opt in to Boost.Thread > 2 to get the std::thread behaviour. I'm not sure what's going to happen if those deprecations result in actually removing the code in a future version of Boost, though.