[Paul] Provisionally, yes.
[Niall] I read the provisional yes as meaning yes to how the library is roadmapped to look like in the future, and he recommends an additional mini-review at that point which could introduce yet another mini-review after again.
In other words, he's saying fundamentally it's good, but needs a lot more work yet.
Paul please do correct me if I am wrong in this interpretation.
[Paul] Correct - and more - "that we wish and trust Niall to get it right - eventually."
That did not sound like a strong "Accept" to me. It sounded more like "Not reject" and "Please resubmit for review [after getting it right, eventually]." Glen -- View this message in context: http://boost.2283326.n4.nabble.com/afio-Formal-review-of-Boost-AFIO-tp467911... Sent from the Boost - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.