Re: [boost] [Async] Peer review report and conditions

On 11/10/2023 16:53, David Sankel wrote:

On Wed, Oct 11, 2023 at 6:25 AM Niall Douglas via Boost mailto:boost@lists.boost.org> wrote:

Proposed Boost.Async by Klemens Morgenstern was reviewed between 8th and 18th August, and again between 22nd September and 2nd October. Reviews or substantially detailed comments came from...

Thanks Niall. Could you please indicate the number of formal Boost reviews that were made and their tally of accept/reject?

I listed the reviews or feedback substantial enough to be worth naming their authors at the top. I intentionally did not list whether they recommended accept or reject. If you want to know that, you can look up the review. I believe all but one was accept, but some gave no formally written recommendation so I had to infer from the body of the feedback. In any case, it does not matter, approval or rejection isn't based on vote counts. Niall