The review of the proposed Boost.Align library ended on April 20, 2014. The result is: Accepted with conditions. Glen and I would like to thank everyone for contributing to the review for Boost.Align. either with a review or comments in the discussions. The summary of formal votes is as follows (alphabetical order): Andrey Semashev - Yes (conditional) Antony Polukhin - Yes (conditional) Bjorn Reese - Yes Lars Viklund - Yes Michael Spencer - Yes For a total of 5 votes for acceptance and 0 votes for rejection. The conditional acceptance is based on the quality of documentation, as the feedback given on code and design has already been addressed. The conditions below are agreeable to the author: 1. QuickBook documentation should be used, following typical Boost documentation structure. 2. Additional examples should be used to make the understanding/use of the library easier. 3. Additional minor comments from the reviews should be addressed. I would like to thank Glen for making this an easy first review manager experience and I look forward to reviewing other libraries in the future.
On Sun, Apr 20, 2014 at 6:55 PM, Ahmed Charles wrote:
The review of the proposed Boost.Align library ended on April 20, 2014. The result is: Accepted with conditions.
I'd like to foremost thank Ahmed sincerely for his management of this review and for all his help. Thank you, again, to Andrey, Antony, Lars, Michael, and Bjorn, for participating in the review and helping improve this library. Thank you to Peter who provided an abundance of guidance and feedback long before this was submitted for review, and to Steven who submitted a very thorough pre-review. And thank you to Paul, who generously volunteered time to help with the documentation. Glen
participants (2)
-
Ahmed Charles -
Glen Fernandes