Phil Endecott wrote:

Adam Wulkiewicz wrote:

...

The formal review of Emil Dotchevski's QVM library begins today on 7th Dec and ends on 16th Dec.

Adam sent this announcement email to the boost@, boost-users@ and boost-announce@lists.boost.org lists. Which seems OK, except that as I have previously noted the gmane.org website seems to get confused by such messages; this announcement will have appeared on only the announce page at gmane.org and any followups that are sent to e.g. the boost@ list will not be displayed by gmane at all.

Thanks about the information. I've reposted the announcement.

You might argue that this is a gmane.org bug, and that is true, but on the other hand we do want everyone who might be interested to know about the review, and a quick look at email headers will show that many do use the gmane.org web interface to read these lists.

I've previously suggested that whatever "how to be a review manager" documentation that exists should advise that announcements should be posted separately to each list. Perhaps no such documentation exists!

There is such documentation: http://www.boost.org/community/reviews.html I've created a pull request with the suggestion.

(I'll post some comments about the actual proposal soon.)

Thanks! Adam